Sabine Hossenfelder, analysis fellow on the Frankfurt Institute for Superior Research, writes: What we’ve right here within the basis of physics is a plain failure of the scientific methodology. All these improper predictions ought to have taught physicists that simply because they’ll write down equations for one thing doesn’t imply this math is a scientifically promising speculation. String concept, supersymmetry, multiverses. There’s math for it, alright. Fairly math, even. However that does not imply this math describes actuality. Physicists want new strategies. Higher strategies. Strategies which can be applicable to the current century. And please spare me the complaints that I supposedly would not have something higher to recommend, as a result of that could be a false accusation. I’ve mentioned many occasions that trying on the historical past of physics teaches us that resolving inconsistencies has been a dependable path to breakthroughs, so that is what we should always concentrate on. I could also be on the improper monitor with this, after all.
Why do not physicists have a tough take a look at their historical past and study from their failure? As a result of the present scientific system doesn’t encourage studying. Physicists as we speak can fortunately make profession by writing papers about issues nobody has ever noticed, and by no means will observe. This continues to go on as a result of there may be nothing and nobody that may cease it. It’s possible you’ll need to put this down as a minor fear as a result of — $40 billion greenback collider apart — who actually cares in regards to the foundations of physics? Perhaps all these string theorists have been losing tax-money for many years, alright, however within the giant scheme of issues it is not all that a lot cash. I grant you that a lot. Theorists will not be costly. However even for those who do not care what’s up with strings and multiverses, it is best to fear about what is occurring right here. The foundations of physics are the canary within the coal mine. It is an previous self-discipline and the primary to run into this drawback. However the identical drawback will ultimately floor in different disciplines if experiments change into more and more costly and recruit giant fractions of the scientific group. Certainly, we see this starting to occur in drugs and in ecology, too.
Learn extra of this story at Slashdot.